31 Best Pizza Places on Maui, HI
During my numerous visits to Maui over the past few years—whether to catch the waves or bask in the island vibe—I’ve made it my mission to seek out the best pizza Maui has to offer.
My husband and I have searched every corner of the island as pizza enthusiasts, from the windswept beaches of Paia to the scenic routes of Lahaina, indulging in everything from mushroom pizza to pineapple-topped specialties.
The memories of sharing a great pizza as the sun sets over the Pacific have become a cherished part of our travels. So trust me when I say that the recommendations that follow come from a place of extensive, hands-on (and taste buds-on!) experience.
Maui, Hawaii, may not be the first destination that comes to mind when you think of pizza. However, the island is home to some of the most delicious and unique pizza places that you can’t miss. Whether you are a pizza lover or just looking to try something new, here are the 31 best pizza places on Maui, HI.
In a hurry? Top 5 Recommendations!
- Papi’s Ohana – The best pizza & supporting the community since the fires
- The Outrigger Pizza Company – The best pizza food truck
- Monkeypod Kitchen – Best Pizza, Mai Tai, and other types of food
- Ocean Vodka Distillery – Best Views
- Round Table Pizza – The best chain supporting the community.
29 Best Pizza Places on Maui
With so much to offer, Maui’s pizza scene is something not to be missed. From food truck excursions and artisan pizzas to beachfront views and the finest local ingredients, these recommended best pizza restaurants will satisfy your cravings while enjoying the beautiful islands.
Kaanapali
1. Sale Pepe Pizzeria e Cucina (Whalers Village)
Already well-known for authentic Neapolitan pizza, its new Whalers Village location is ideal for visitors staying or shopping in Kāʻanapali.
2. Monkeypod Kitchen (Whalers Village)
Variety of pizzas, including Wild Mushroom and Kalua Pork & Pineapple.
3. Round Table Pizza Maui
A classic pizza chain in Lahaina.
4. Papi’s Ohana
Known for their delicious wood-fired pizzas with a Hawaiian twist.
5. Pailolo Bar & Grill at The Westin Ka’anapali Ocean Resort Villas
Enjoy their signature pizzas while taking in ocean views.
6. Nikki’s Pizza (closing 1/31/2025 😢 )
Located in Whalers Village, is known for Maui-style pizza.
Kahana
7. Dollie’s Pub and Cafe
Sports bar with a variety of hand-pressed pizzas.
Kihei
8. Pizza Madness
Known for its secret pizza dough recipe.
9. Fabiani’s Bakery and Pizza
Cozy atmosphere with Maui Sunrise fresh pizza.
10. Black Rock Pizza
Located in the Azeka Shopping Center. Choose your toppings or try their popular Pineapple Delight pizza.
11. Penny’s Pizza & Pasta
Fresh, locally sourced ingredients in their pizzas.
12. Kihei Caffe
They offer delicious breakfast pizzas in addition to their traditional pizzas.
Wailea
13. Manoli’s Pizza Company
Offers gourmet pizzas with locally sourced ingredients.
14. Matteo’s Osteria
Wood-fired pizzas, including the popular Maui Gold pizza with prosciutto and pineapple.
15. Mulligan’s on the Blue
Oceanfront views and a variety of unique pizzas, like their Ahi Poke pizza.
16. Monkeypod Kitchen (Wailea)
Offers pizzas like Hamakua Wild Mushroom and Asian Pear Arugula and has a great happy hour.
17. Ferraro’s Bar e Ristorante at Four Seasons Maui
Enjoy ocean views while indulging in their specialty pizzas, like the Prosciutto e Rucola with arugula and prosciutto di Parma.
Upcountry Maui – Kula & Pukalani:
18. Kula Lodge Restaurant and Garden Terrace
Pizzas cooked in an outdoor wood-fired brick oven.
19. Ocean Vodka Distillery
An organic farm and distillery in Maui, known for its vodka.
20. Restaurant Marlow
Sourdough pizza option in the upcountry area.
Paia
21. Flatbread Company
A popular pizza chain in the Paia location is known for its organic, wood-fired flatbread pizza made with local ingredients.
Kahului
22. Round Table Pizza
A classic pizza chain near the airport
Wailuku
23. Giannotto’s Pizzeria
A family-owned pizzeria with New York-style pizza.
Haiku
24. Wood-Fired Pizza at Jaws Country Store
This restaurant offers unique Neapolitan-style pizzas with local ingredients.
Notable Food Trucks Serving Pizza
25. The Outrigger Pizza Company
Known for their lilikoi pork pizza in Kihei.
26. Da Grateful Dough Pizza
In Kahului one of the Costco food trucks at 553 Haleakala Hwy across from Costco Gas Station. Has a unique Maui Pizza menu including venison.
27. Kamala’s Kitchen
Olowalu near Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop on Honoapiilani Hwy.
Other Notable Mentions
28. Maui Brewing Company
In Kaanapali and Kihei, a Brewery with delicious pizzas.
29. Pizza Paradiso Mediterranean Grill
Mediterranean-inspired pizzas.
30. Costco Pizza and Deli
A surprise to many, but Costco’s pizza is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
31. Hana Farms The Bamboo Hale Grill and Pizzeria
This spot is new to my list, and while I haven’t had the chance to try it yet, I’ve heard great things! It’s located on the road to Hana, so be sure to stop by and give it a try. Let me know how their farm-to-table pizza measures up!
Lahaina
Regrettably, three beloved pizza establishments fell victim to the devastating Lahaina fires in August 2023. We hold a special fondness for all three, and we hope they will be rebuilt in the future.
Sale Pepe: Artisan pizzas with local fresh ingredients. NOW OPEN IN WHALER’s Village see #6
Prison Street Pizza: Jersey-style pizza in Old Lahaina Town.
Lahaina Pizza Company: Offers pizza with ocean views.
Best Pizza Delivery
This comprehensive list offers a blend of traditional pizza spots and food trucks across Maui, catering to a range of tastes and dining preferences. Whether you’re looking for a classic restaurant experience or a unique menu from a food truck, these places are sure to enhance your Maui culinary journey.
- Pizza Madness Maui – Website
- Outrigger Pizza Company – Website
- Dollie’s Pub & Café – Website
- Fabiani’s – Website
- Manoli’s Pizza Company – Website
- Shaka Sandwich & Pizza – Website
Our Current Favorite Pizza Place on Maui
And now, let me introduce you to Papi Ohana —our current favorite and a place that truly embodies the aloha spirit. Not only will their pizza make your taste buds dance with delight thanks to freshly made-to-order pies topped with vibrant, local ingredients, but it’s their heartwarming dedication to Maui’s community that has captured ours in return.
After the devastation of the Lahaina fires, Papi Ohana didn’t just focus on rebuilding—they became a pillar of hope and support for the community. Their work to give back, ranging from organizing fundraisers to donating pizza to locals, is truly inspiring.
So, if you’re on Maui and craving some of the best pizza Maui has to offer, Papi Ohana is the place to go. Not only will you be treated to a delicious meal, but you’ll also be supporting a business that cares deeply for its island home. See you there, pizza enthusiasts! 🍕❤️
Frequently Ask Questions (FAQs) for Best Pizza on Maui
Curious about the best pizza on Maui? Look no further! Here are some frequently asked questions to help guide you in choosing the perfect slice.
What makes a pizza place stand out as one of the best on Maui?
Each pizza place has its unique qualities that make it stand out, whether it’s through their use of local ingredients, their specific cooking techniques, or their scenic location. Ultimately, the best pizza on Maui is a combination of well-made pizzas and an overall enjoyable dining experience.
Are there any food trucks on Maui that serve amazing pizza?
Yes! Some of the best pizza on Maui can be found at food trucks such as Outrigger Pizza Truck, Da Grateful Dough, and Dollie’s Pub & Café. These places offer a more casual and laid-back atmosphere, perfect for quick service and grabbing a quick bite while exploring the island.
Is there a specific pizza that Maui is known for?
While Maui isn’t necessarily known for a specific type of pizza, it does have its own unique flavors thanks to locally-sourced ingredients. Some popular toppings include Maui pineapple, artichoke hearts, Hawaiian Goat Cheese, local meats such as kalua pork or Portuguese sausage, and fresh seafood like shrimp or ahi tuna.
Are there any pizza places on Maui that offer gluten-free options?
Yes! Many of the best pizza places on Maui are accommodating to dietary restrictions. For example, Fabiani’s offers gluten-free crust options for their pizzas, and Manoli’s Pizza Company has a gluten-free pizza menu with a variety of toppings to choose from.
Are there any vegetarian or vegan-friendly pizza places on Maui?
Definitely! Places like Flatbread Company and Pizzeria Paradiso offer delicious vegetarian and vegan options, made with fresh and locally-sourced quality ingredients. These pizzas are just as flavorful and satisfying as their meaty counterparts.
Which pizza place on Maui should I try first?
It ultimately depends on personal preference, but some highly recommended pizza places to try first include Papa Ohana for their mouth-watering wood-fired pizzas, Kihei Caffe in Kihei for their unique breakfast pizzas, and Fabiani’s for their delicious gluten-free and vegan options.
Can I find a good slice of New York-style pizza on the island?
Yes, there are a few places on Maui that serve New York-style pizza! One popular spot is the Giannotto’s Pizzeria, known for their authentic thin crust pizzas and lively atmosphere.
Are reservations recommended for any of these pizza restaurants?
It is always a good idea to make reservations at popular pizza places on Maui, especially during peak tourist seasons. However, some places like Flatbread Company and Pizzeria Paradiso do not take reservations and operate on a first-come, first-served basis. It is recommended to call ahead or check the restaurant’s website for their reservation policy.
Which pizza place on Maui has the best ocean views?
Monkeypod Kitchen – With locations in Wailea and Kaanapali, Monkeypod Kitchen offers not only a diverse menu with delicious pizzas but also stunning ocean views, especially from their Kaanapali location at Whalers Village.
The ambiance and the view make it a perfect spot for those looking to enjoy a meal with scenic vistas. For more details, visit their website: Monkeypod Kitchen.
The Wrap-Up: Best Pizza in Maui, Hawaii
Maui, Hawaii may not be known for its pizza, but it certainly has some hidden gems worth exploring. With this list of the 29 best pizza places on the island, you can indulge in delicious and unique pizzas that you won’t find anywhere else.
From the thin-crust pizzas of Pizza Paradiso to the creative toppings of Manoli’s Pizza Company, there is something for everyone. So what are you waiting for? Grab a slice (or two) and experience the flavors of Maui!
Hungry for more than just pizza on your Maui adventure? I’ve got you covered! Don’t miss out on my blog posts about Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop for the best pies on the island, Mama’s Fish House for a seafood extravaganza, and Gazebos for breakfast with a view.
These spots are beloved by locals and travelers alike, and I’ve shared all the tasty details, including what to try and insider tips to make your visit unforgettable. Just click, read, and get ready to add these must-visit eateries to your Maui itinerary!
