Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop in Maui Review: Is It Worth It?

Why Leoda’s is a Must-Visit Spot?

First off, let’s talk about the food. As someone who considers themselves a pie expert, my husband was blown away by the banana cream pie from Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop. It was so good that he declared it the best he’s ever had! And trust me, we’ve tried a lot of pies. But it’s not just the pie that makes Leoda’s stand out – their sandwiches are also top-notch.

During our recent visit to Maui, we decided to pick up some sandwiches and a pie to-go. After an exciting snorkeling adventure in Turtle Town, we returned to the hotel in Kaanapali.

As we enjoyed our meal, we relished the breathtaking view of the ocean from our hotel balcony. The fresh ingredients and attention to detail in every dish are what sets Leoda’s apart from the rest.

Worth the Visit?

So, is Leoda’s worth adding to your Maui itinerary? Absolutely. Not only is the food exceptional, but the overall experience of dining at Leoda’s is one of a kind. It’s become one of the must-visit best restaurants for us on every trip to Maui and I have no doubt it will become one for you too. So make sure to stop by Leoda’s on your next trip – your taste buds (and stomach) will thank you!

A Personal Touch

Aside from the food, what really makes Leoda’s special is the personal touch they bring to everything they do. From the friendly staff to the cozy atmosphere, you feel like you’re part of a big family when you dine at Leoda’s. It’s clear that they take pride in their food and want every customer to have a memorable experience. And trust me, you will.

Pies, Pies, and More Great Pies!

Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop is famous for its hand-crafted pies, sandwiches, and artisanal bread. The bakery specializes in pies, offering a wide variety of flavors ranging from traditional apple to macadamia nut chocolate, and of course, my favorite, the banana cream pie. They are made in-house, using the freshest ingredients, and you can also place an order for a whole pie to take back to your hotel or condominium. If you’re a fan of pie, you won’t be disappointed by the selection on offer here, including the yummy flaky crust.

• Banana Cream Pie – This is the pie that put Leoda’s on the map! It’s made with a buttery crust, fresh bananas, vanilla custard and topped with whipped cream. One bite of this heavenly creation and you’ll see why it’s a must-try.
• Chocolate Macadamia Nut Pie – A rich chocolate filling mixed with crunchy macadamia nuts creates the perfect balance of sweet and nutty flavors. It’s a must for chocolate lovers.
• Coconut Cream Pie – A close second to the banana cream pie, this one has a flaky crust filled with creamy coconut custard and topped with a generous amount of whipped cream.
• Olowalu Lime Pie – Made with the famous Olowalu limes grown right here on Maui, this tangy and refreshing pie is perfect for a hot day.
• Leoda’s Classic Apple Pie – You can’t go wrong with a classic apple pie! Leoda’s version has perfectly baked apples in a flaky crust, topped with streusel for an extra crunch.

PRO TIP: Our favorite is the Banana Cream Pie!

Leoda’s Menu

In addition to their delectable pies, Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop in Maui boasts a diverse menu. Below is a summary:

1. Sandwiches: A variety of options, including classics like Reuben, Ham’n, and Club, along with unique choices like Seared Ahi Tuna Sandwich and toppings like caramelized onion, garlic aioli, and local basil pesto.
2. Burgers, Dogs, and Fries: Features a selection of burgers, including a Mushroom Swiss and Blue Cheese Burger, alongside hot dogs like the Lahaina Dog and Upcountry Hot Dog, complemented by hand-cut fries.
3. Salads: Offers fresh choices like the Out of the Garden Salad, Fried Salad, Caesar Salad, and Cobb Salad.
4. For the Kids at Heart: Includes kid-friendly options such as a plain hot dog, grilled cheese, PB&J, and a kids’ cheeseburger.
5. Pies: Highlights their famous pies like Banana Cream, Chocolate Mac Nut, Coconut Cream, Olowalu Lime, and Apple Crumb.
6. Baked Goods: Features items like Mini Banana Bread Loaf and Leoda’s Chocolate Chip Cookie.
7. Beverages: A range of drinks including house-made lemonade, brewed iced tea, coffee, cold brew iced coffee, and sodas.

For more details and to view the full menu, visit Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop’s website.

PRO TIP: We love the sandwiches. I have had the roast beef, the ham with Jarlsberg Cheese on Rye Bread, and the BLT. My husband is a vegetarian and loves the Avocado and Cucumber and the Veggie Burger!

Vegetarian Options

Leoda’s is renowned for its delectable pies and sandwiches, which are complemented by an array of incredible vegetarian offerings. Among the noteworthy seasonal dishes are the Veggie Chili, Avocado Toast, and Portobello Mushroom Sandwich. Here are a few other vegetarian options that are a definite must-try at Leoda’s:

• Avocado & Cucumber Sandwich – A refreshing combination of avocado and cucumber served on homemade wheat bread.
• Out of the Garden Salad – Simple yet satisfying, this salad features fresh greens, tomatoes, cucumber, carrots, balsamic vinaigrette, and a slice of house bread.
• Veggie Burger – Made with a house-made veggie patty, this burger is served with all the fixings and a side of crispy fries.

The Decor and Ambience

The interior of Leoda’s, with its vintage decor in the style of an old plantation store, is a real treat. The open bakery layout allows you to watch the talented bakers at work, crafting delicious pies and creating sandwiches with freshly baked bread.

The atmosphere is relaxed and casual, making it the perfect spot to visit with family or friends. The staff provides an incredibly friendly service, makes sure that your experience at Leoda’s is memorable, and will recommend the must-try dishes on their menu.

The Popular Demand

It’s common to see a long line outside Leoda’s. This beloved pie shop has gained quite a reputation, and locals and tourists alike flock to indulge in their famous pies. But don’t let the line deter you, as it moves quickly and is worth the wait for a taste of their great desserts.

Plus, it’s a great opportunity to chat with other pie enthusiasts and swap recommendations for your next visit to Leoda’s.

The prices at Leoda’s are reasonable, although some might find it pricey compared to other Maui dining options. They offer excellent value for money, with portions that are generous for the price.

A single mini pie costs $10, but it’s worth the price for its heavenly taste and high-quality local ingredients. Sandwiches cost around $15, with salads and entrees priced at around the same price range. Their combo options are worth considering, too.

PRO TIP: A good way to end your Maui stay is to stop by on your way to the Kahului airport and pick up sandwiches and a pie for each to eat on your way home.

Location and Hours

Leoda’s is located in the historic Olowalu Town on Maui’s west side, just off Highway 30 at 820 Olowalu Village Road, Lahaina, HI. It is a perfect stop during your road trip around the island. They are open daily from 10:00 AM to 6:00 PM, so you can satisfy your pie cravings throughout the day.

Adjacent to the premises, you’ll find a convenient general store offering a variety of miscellaneous items for your convenience.

Our Experience at Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop

I first heard about Leoda’s from a travel group that raved about their banana cream pie. My husband and I decided to give it a try on our next trip to Maui, and we were blown away by the quality of their pies. We’ve been regulars ever since, making sure to stop by after snorkeling or doing other tours on the island.

On one particular trip, we decided to try something new and ordered their BLTs for our flight home from the Kahului Airport in Maui. It was a game-changer!

Not only did we have a delicious meal on the plane, but we also received envious looks from other passengers. We couldn’t help but feel like VIPs as we indulged in our Leoda’s sandwiches and Banana Cream Pie at 35,000 feet.

This is one of our favorite meals in Maui, including the individual-sized pie and delicious sandwiches.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop

We understand that you may have some questions about this popular pie shop, so we’ve compiled a list of commonly asked questions to help you out.

The Wrap-Up: Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop Review

Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop is worth a visit if you’re in Maui and want to experience a unique food experience. While it may be a bit more expensive than some other dining options, the quality of the food, coupled with the friendly staff and relaxed atmosphere, makes it a great spot to visit with friends and family.

Head to this bakery and restaurant, indulge yourself in their pies and sandwiches and enjoy all that the island has to offer. To sum it all up, if you’re a food enthusiast, Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop is a destination you don’t want to miss out on.

And while you’re at it, make sure to check out other amazing food spots on the island, such as The Gazebo and Mama’s Fish House.

Related Topics

• Where to Stay on Maui 2023: Best Areas, Towns, and Hotels
• Kaanapali Beach Hotel: Review, Dining, Amenities, Things to Do
• Best Reef Safe Sunscreen to Use in Hawaii to Protect Your Skin and the Coral Reefs
• Can You Drive to Hawaii? Exploring the Possibility of an Epic Road Trip