Mama’s Fish House Maui Review: Is it Worth it?
Absolutely! Here’s our review of Mama’s Fish House, exploring whether it’s truly worth a visit. We weren’t planning to visit Mama’s Fish House in Paia on Maui back in May of 2021 because of all the reviews we saw saying it was expensive and not worth the money, but I’m so glad we decided to give it a try.Â
We are not foodies and tend to eat at less expensive restaurants. In the case of Mama’s, a family-owned restaurant, we decided that for our 29th wedding anniversary, we would splurge and are so glad we did.
We have been back to Maui six times since then, and Mama’s experience is one of the highlights of our trips to Maui and has become our favorite place to dine on Maui. The food, including fresh fish, service, and view, is excellent.
Whether you have a special occasion like we did on our first visit or just want to enjoy a fabulous meal for a perfect ending to the day, Mama’s Fish House delivers.
How is Mama’s Fish House Rated?
Rated as one of the top Maui restaurants for the best food and spectacular views. If you want additional feedback, check out the reviews on OpenTable, Facebook, Google, and Tripadvisor below.
Facebook 86% Recommend with 29,000+ reviews
Google 4.7 with 9,300+ reviews
Tripadvisor travelers 4.5 with 15,000+ reviews
- Food: 5
- Service: 4.5
- Value: 4
- Atmosphere: 5
Customer Quote
Exceptional Food; Outstanding Service.
We had lunch here earlier this week. This is our 2nd time visiting this restaurant. This is by far the best restaurant we have eaten at on any of the Hawaiian islands. The food is exceptional and EVERY dish explodes with incredible flavor. The service is outstanding. The value for what you pay for is top-notch. Make your reservations very early as the popularity of this dining spot makes availability a real challenge as you get closer to your desired date. We booked 6 months in advance to get the time and date we wanted. We did not want to run the risk of missing out.
684timothyr from Palatine, Illnois Tripadvisor
Mama’s Fish House Menu
Mama’s Fish House offers an innovative daily menu that changes frequently to take advantage of the freshest ingredients and fish from local waters.
The variety of dishes is sure to satisfy everyone in your group, with traditional favorites such as seafood chowder, mahi mahi tacos, fresh salads, and ahi poke alongside other unique creations like seared wahoo and grilled baby octopus.
Their signature dishes, like the mahi-mahi encrusted with macadamia nuts, papaya seed dressing, and fresh pineapple chutney, are truly amazing. For those looking for something a bit more exotic, try the Pupu Platter, which features local delicacies such as squid luau, lomi salmon, and Kalua pork.Â
There is also a full bar with signature cocktails, including Mai Tais and an extensive list of wines that pair perfectly with their dishes. Whether you’re looking for a special occasion dinner or just a relaxing meal with friends, Mama’s Fish House is sure to please.
Is lunch or dinner better?
Both lunch and dinner at Mama’s Fish House are great. The menu options, portion sizes, and prices are all the same, so it really just comes down to your preference. Lunch and dinner offer an intimate setting with waves crashing against the shore in the background.
Whether you arrive during the day or night, your dining experience is guaranteed to be unforgettable. However, make sure to plan accordingly if you want to take in the panoramic view – it won’t be visible after dark!
How is the desert?
The desserts at Mama’s Fish House are truly delicious and a perfect way to top off your meal. Choose from classic favorites like Polynesian Black Pearl, or try one of their house specialties like the Warm Banana Macadamia Nut Crisp served with coconut ice cream. No matter what you choose, you won’t be disappointed. Enjoy!
What if I don’t eat Fish?
No problem! Mama’s Fish House offers a variety of non-seafood options, such as Grilled Steak, Short Ribs, Roasted Chicken Breast, and more. No matter what type of eater you are, you’re sure to find something that satisfies your craving.
What would I order if I’m Vegan?
Mama’s Fish House has a variety of vegan options, such as the Roasted Eggplant with Kalamata Olives and Macadamia Nuts or the Tofu Teriyaki Bowl. You can also build your own salad with fresh local ingredients for a lighter meal. The servers are very helpful in designing a Vegan or Vegetarian appetizer or entree.
Mama’s Fish House Location
Mama’s Fish House Restaurant is conveniently located on Maui’s north shore, only 1.4 miles past Paia town along the renowned Road to Hana. Keep an eye out for their welcoming sign; you can’t miss it! A fishing boat adorned with colorful nautical flags will greet visitors and signal they have arrived at Mama’s Fish House.
The restaurant is located in a coconut grove surrounded by palm trees with a view of Mama’s Beach on Kuau Cove.
For those traveling from one of two local resort areas or nearby airports, here are directions to get there: (click here for directions).
Here is the address:
Valet parking is provided and highly suggested because of the limited space in the parking lot.
How do I get reservations at Mama’s Fish House?
If you’re planning to visit Mama’s Fish House, we recommend making your reservations as early as possible. Reservations can be made online via SEVENROOMS on our website or by calling the restaurant directly at (808)-579-8488.
Advanced booking is recommended due to Mama’s Fish House’s popularity and limited seating capacity.
If you are planning on going during peak times, such as holidays or weekends, you may want to book even earlier. Overall, Mama’s Fish House is a great place to visit if you’re looking for an enjoyable dining experience while in Maui. The food is top-notch, and the setting can’t be beaten.
Whether you’re celebrating something special or just looking for a great place to eat, Mama’s Fish House is sure to exceed your expectations. Bon appetite! Happy dining! 🙂
How far out can you book Mama’s Fish House?
Mama’s Fish House is a popular destination, and reservations are highly recommended. Reservations can be made up to twelve months in advance, which gives you plenty of time to plan your visit. If you’re looking for a reservation on the same day or the next day, it’s best to call ahead, as availability may be limited due to the restaurant’s popularity.
Don’t forget to mention any special occasions you might be celebrating – Mama’s Fish House can make your experience even more memorable with professional service and tailored menu options. Enjoy your delicious meal! 🙂
Contact Information
- Phone: (808) 579-8488.
- Email: info@mamasfishhouse.com.
Happy Hour
Mama’s Fish House offers happy hour specials daily from 4-6 pm. Enjoy a selection of delicious appetizers, as well as discounted cocktails and wines. Stop by for a relaxing afternoon or evening of good food and great company! 🙂
Top Things to Do Close By
There are plenty of activities to enjoy close by Mama’s Fish House, and it’s a great way to make the most out of your trip. From outdoor adventures to cultural attractions, there is something for everyone nearby. And if you are visiting from mid-December to mid-April, look for whales. Here are some of the top things to do:
Paia Town
Home to unique shops, cafes, and art galleries, Paia town offers something for everyone. Enjoy a tropical smoothie and explore this charming town.
Book a private tour to Hana, Turtle Town, and Winery (up to 14)
Turtles (and surfers) Ho’okipa Beach Park
Just down the road, the Ho’okipa Beach Park is home to some of the best surfing in Maui. Watch the locals catch waves or take a leisurely stroll along the beach and spot some sea turtles!
Maui Winery
Just a few minutes away, Maui Winery is the perfect spot to sample some of the island’s finest wines. Enjoy a tour and tasting with friends or family!
Road to Hana
Take the legendary Hana Highway for a stunning drive with incredible views. Stop along the way to take in breathtaking waterfalls and swimming holes! Book your Road to Hana Tour
Ocean Vodka Organic Farms and Distillery Tour
Enjoy the opportunity to visit Ocean Vodka Organic Farms and Distillery, where I learned about their sustainable farming practices and sampled their delicious organic vodka.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) for Mama’s Fish House Review
Mama’s Fish House is a popular destination, and it often sparks questions from visitors about reservations, happy hour specials, and things to do nearby. To help you plan your visit, here are some frequently asked questions about Mama’s Fish House!
Mama’s offers the most delightful seafood spread in town. Our ever-changing menu features fresh catches from talented fishermen—all of whom are listed alongside their delectable dishes!
But it doesn’t stop there; we also offer succulent lobster tails, short ribs, and steak so delicious that you won’t believe your taste buds. Alas, these exceptional delights come at an extravagant price tag of around $75 per entree.
What you need to know before you go
No, there is no dress code at Mama’s Fish House. We recommend wearing semi-formal attire as it will add to the overall elegance and ambiance of your experience. However, feel free to come as you like! The staff won’t judge; they’ll just be delighted that you decided to join them for a delicious meal.
Open Daily 11:00 am -8:30 pm
Mama’s Fish House is a very popular destination, and reservations are highly recommended. Although it is possible to walk in without a reservation, availability may be limited due to the restaurant’s popularity.
It’s best to book ahead of time if you can. Alternatively, you can always call ahead on the day of your visit and inquire about any last-minute openings.
The average cost for one person at Mama’s Fish House is about $75 for an entree. However, prices can vary depending on what you order and the quantity. Additionally, if you plan to take a bottle of wine with your meal, that will be an additional charge.
Additional Information about Mama’s
Mama’s Fish House opened its doors in 1973. Today, it is one of the most popular seafood restaurants in Maui, and reservations are highly recommended. The restaurant offers a unique, ever-changing menu featuring fresh catches from local fishermen. Stop by for a delicious meal and experience the best of what Maui has to offer!
No, as the sun sets on the opposite side of the island. However, the restaurant’s view of the ocean and nearby beach park is still stunning! Enjoy a meal with friends or family and take in the peaceful views around you.
Mama’s Fish House is the perfect destination for your next romantic dinner or special occasion, boasting stunning landscaped gardens that are sure to make it a memorable experience.
Yes, Mama’s Fish House has a bar where you can enjoy cocktails, wines, and other drinks. They also offer happy hour specials daily from 4-6 pm, featuring discounted drinks and appetizers. Enjoy the sunset views while sipping on your favorite beverage!
The Wrap-Up: Mama’s Fish House Review: Is it Worth Visiting?
In conclusion, Mama’s Fish House is worth visiting if you’re looking for an unforgettable experience with fabulous food on Maui. The ever-changing menu features fresh seafood from local fishermen, as well as succulent short ribs and delicious steak.
With a relaxed dress code and stunning views of the ocean, this restaurant is perfect for a romantic dinner or a special occasion. The bar also offers happy hour specials, so you can enjoy discounted drinks and appetizers while watching the waves. So, if you’re looking for a delicious seafood meal and stunning views, Mama’s Fish House is definitely worth a visit.
We ate lunch at Mama’s with a 2:00 reservation and then headed up to Haleakala for the sunset.
Other posts you may find helpful!
- Gazebo Restaurant Maui Review: Is it worth the wait in line?
- Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop in Maui Review
- Best Time to See Whales in Hawaii
- Best Whale Watching Tours in Maui: When are Whales in Maui?
- Is Kualoa Ranch Worth Visiting in Oahu
- Is Haleakala Sunset or Sunrise Better? Why and How to See Both
- Maui from a Cruise Ship: 27 Shore Excursions In Kahului & Lahaina
- Kaanapali Beach Hotel: Review, Dining, Amenities, Things to Do
- Maui to Lanai Ferry: An Easy and Affordable Transportation Option
- Turtle Town Snorkeling Maui: From Shore Tour Review
- Visiting Kona Cruise Port
- Recommended Travel Resources
- Great Accessories for Flights
Need a flight to Hawaii?
Book now on Kayak.com, and get a deal.
